COLLUDE Act Would Chill—Not Protect—Free Speech, Knight Institute Says
Sections
WASHINGTON—Tomorrow, the Senate Commerce Committee is scheduled to mark up the “Curtailing Online Limitations that Lead Unconstitutionally to Democracy’s Erosion (COLLUDE) Act,” which would strip Section 230 protection from platforms that restrict access to or availability of content containing political speech in response to requests by governmental or even nongovernmental entities, unless the requests serve legitimate law enforcement or national security purposes.
The following can be attributed to Carrie DeCell, senior staff attorney and legislative advisor at the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University:
“The COLLUDE Act completely misses the mark. Rather than restrict government officials from coercing platforms into censoring their users’ speech, this bill would punish platforms for engaging in their own First Amendment–protected activity, all while chilling permissible speech by the government and protected speech by nongovernmental actors.”
Earlier this year, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia concluded in CITR v. Rubio, a case brought by the Knight Institute, that a Trump administration policy subjecting noncitizen platform researchers, advocates, fact-checkers, and trust and safety workers to visa denials and revocations, detention, and deportation based on their work likely violated the First Amendment. The administration characterized their work as “censorship,” but as the court explained, this “asserted ‘censorship’ consists of studying platforms, reporting on disinformation, petitioning for access to platform data, and urging platforms or advertisers to act on what they find”—all work that the First Amendment protects. Read more about that case here.
The Knight Institute has endorsed the Justice Against Weaponized Bureaucratic Overreach to Networked Expression (JAWBONE) Act, a bipartisan bill that would create new safeguards against government coercion of private speech intermediaries, including social media platforms, broadcasters, and providers of AI systems.
For more information, contact: [email protected].