Essays & Scholarship

Chapter 14: Top 100: The most popular social media platforms and what they can teach us

An Illustrated Field Guide to Social Media

Chapter title page from An Illustrated Field Guide to Social Media: Top 100
Read time 14 min.

Sections

    The most popular social media platforms and what they can teach us

    Moving past U.S. and Facebook centrism

    Top 100

    Constructing a top 100 list wasn’t easy. There’s no official “registry” of website traffic that serves as a “league table” for social media. Instead, there’s a variety of tools used by the advertising industry to choose where to purchase ads. Some of these tools work by auditing website traffic logs; others track a panel of users to estimate traffic to different sites. These methods are not consistent across providers, and it’s therefore difficult to come up with a decisive ranking of the most visited websites, especially once you get beyond the most highly trafficked. Besides that, as we’ll discuss here, it’s not at all clear what websites should be considered “social media.”

    For our initial data collection, we used a combination of Similarweb’s list of the top 100 social networks and online communities,1 Alexa’s list of the top 500 sites on the web,2 and Wikipedia’s list of social networking services.3 (The initial collection was done in November 2020.) Measurement sites like Similarweb and Alexa aren’t perfect tools for measuring popularity. They focus mostly on website traffic, which means they can be blind to mobile usage. However, the two services are complementary: Alexa uses a panel to measure what sites users visit, while Similarweb relies on “first-party direct measurement”—the logs maintained by website providers. We aren’t claiming this list is definitive or comprehensive, but we do believe it offers a rough picture of the most popular social media platforms worldwide.

    As we compiled our list, it became clear that social is eating the world. Many, many websites and apps have some social features. This made deciding what to classify as social media difficult. Are dating sites like Tinder and Hinge social media? Are wikis like Wikipedia and Namu.wiki social media? What about content subscription sites like OnlyFans or Patreon? Our definition of a social media platform from the initial post in our series was: “a digital space that combines communicating or sharing media with aspects of social networking sites.” We think this definition still holds up but must be sharpened to deal with the pervasiveness of social features.

    To help us with line-drawing, we settled on a subjective test: Is the platform in question more like “a site with social features” or is it “social first”? Consider The New York Times, which has a comment section on many of its online articles, or Amazon, which hosts customer reviews and discussions on product pages. We wouldn’t call The New York Times or Amazon a social media platform. They are, respectively, a news website with social features and an online retailer with social features. Same goes for Wikipedia—it’s a collaborative online encyclopedia with social features, not a social media platform. Dating sites were more difficult, but in the end, we decided that they were more akin to platforms like Uber which operate two-sided marketplaces—i.e., Tinder is a matchmaking platform with social features. Similarly, we decided that content subscription sites like OnlyFans, Patreon, and Substack are closer to being transaction platforms than platforms for sociality. (This could change if they achieve widespread adoption and add features like content aggregation. Today, these platforms are dominated by paid subscriptions to a small group of creators, but if they shift toward being dominated by content uploaded by the general public, it may make more sense to think of them as falling under creator logic.)

    In the end, our definition and the lines we drew aren’t the “right” way to define social media. They are just one way that’s useful for our purposes.

    After we determined a platform fit our definition of social media, we then categorized it by logic and by country. When assigning a platform’s country, we assigned the country that was the source of the most visitors to the platform, as reported by Alexa.

    Top 100 Analysis

    The full top 100 list can be found at the end of this chapter, with a downloadable version available.4 It is sorted in order of Alexa rank. (For platforms with popular mobile apps, we estimated their Alexa rank by using monthly active user numbers.) We urge you to avoid overfocusing on any one platform’s rank, inclusion, or omission, though do feel free to ask about a platform you think was left out. As we said above, this is an attempt to offer a rough picture of the most popular social media platforms worldwide, not to provide a definitive or comprehensive ranking. We think the list is most useful for higher-level analysis, such as comparing the popularity of different logics or exploring the popularity of platforms by country.

    Some Brief Observations

    First, the large number of non-U.S. platforms that were in the top 100 surprised us and was a healthy reminder of our U.S. centrism. They made up the majority of the list, comprising 61 of the top 100. However, maybe it shouldn’t be so surprising given, for example, that there are more than 900 million Chinese internet users who use popular Chinese social media platforms, including Sina Weibo, Douyin, and WeChat. Even platforms based in the U.S. that serve a large number of Americans sometimes serve more users from a different country. Take Quora: The country with the most visitors to Quora, according to Alexa, is India, which makes up 36 percent of traffic, followed by the U.S., with 28 percent of traffic.

    Next, we analyzed the popularity of different logics in our top 100. We assessed the popularity of each logic with this formula: Take all the platforms that fall under a given logic and sum their points, where points are assigned in order, from most popular (by Alexa rank) to least popular. The most popular platform receives 100 points, the next most popular receives 99 points, all the way down to the least popular platform in the top 100, which receives 1 point. This allows us to capture a logic’s frequency in the top 100 while also incorporating the magnitude of each platform’s popularity. So a logic with 10 platforms ranked toward the bottom of the top 100 won’t appear more popular than a logic that has five platforms that are all in the top 10. The results of that analysis follow:

    LogicPopularity Score
    Creator1285
    Social Network978
    Chat958
    Subculture949
    Q&A461
    Chan140
    Social Bookmarking113
    Local62
    Enterprise Social Network46
    Alt-Tech42
    Crypto16
    Figure 3. Logics in order of popularity score
    Bubble chart of social media logics sized by popularity score: Creator, Social Network, Chat and Subculture are the largest circles, followed by Q&A; Local, Alt-Tech, Chan, Enterprise Social Network, Social Bookmarking and Crypto are small
    Figure 4. Logics sized by popularity score

    (Circles are sized proportionally by each logic’s popularity score)

    The most popular logic was creator logic. The popularity of creator logic and its relative lack of attention in comparison to social network logic suggests that journalists, scholars, and activists should direct more energy toward scrutinizing and understanding it.

    Following creator logic in popularity were social network, chat, and subculture logic, respectively. The popularity of social network logic is no surprise. It covers dominant social networks like Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and LinkedIn, social networks that are run by a single company, for the use of anyone for a variety of purposes, supported by advertising. Similarly, chat logic’s popularity isn’t surprising—chat platforms such as WhatsApp, Snapchat, and Discord boast some of the largest user numbers in the world and are hosting more and more of our social life online. Finally, subculture logic covers platforms that are organized around various subcultures. This logic is overwhelmingly populated by internet forums and their descendants—sites like Reddit, Steam Community, and Ubuntu Forums—but also includes sites like Ravelry, a social network for yarn enthusiasts, and Letterboxd, a social network for film lovers. Subculture logic, like creator logic, receives less attention than it deserves. One possible reason is that they are less popular among journalists, academics, and politicians, who mostly use Twitter or Facebook.

    A surprise in the findings was the popularity of Q&A logic. It was the fifth most popular logic, occupying a middle tier between the dominant logics and the more niche logics. Q&A platforms are organized around users submitting questions and answers. Some are focused on a specific domain, like Stack Overflow, which serves mostly programmers, while others are more general-purpose like Quora. Q&A is a social media logic that is rarely in the spotlight, perhaps because it is particularly popular with communities that are less visible (programmers, students) and nations outside the U.S. (notably India). It clearly deserves more attention given its popularity.

    What logics didn’t make the top-100? Civic and decentralized. Their omission makes sense. Civic logic is an emerging idea that hasn’t received enough traction to make a list like this one yet. Also, civic logic platforms typically cater to smaller communities. As we put it in our chapter about them, civic platforms “are likely limited to communities of a few dozen to a few thousand.” Decentralized platforms face serious challenges to their adoption, specifically, they must “address their usability difficulties and overcome the massive network effects of centralized platforms.”

    To supplement our popularity score analysis, we provide a bar chart with the raw frequency of each logic in the top 100 broken down by whether a platform was categorized as a U.S. platform or a non-U.S. platform. We also include a table with the average popularity scores for select logics.

    Stacked bar chart of how many top 100 platforms use each logic, U.S. vs. non-U.S.: Subculture leads (about 29), then Creator, Social Network, Chat, Q&A and Chan; the other five logics have one to three each
    Figure 5. Logic frequency in top 100
    LogicAverage Popularity Score
    Chat80
    Creator61
    Social Network61
    Q&A58
    Subculture33
    Figure 6. Logics in order of average popularity

    The raw frequencies provide some useful context about the popularity results, highlighting differences between logics and nuances that aren’t clear from the popularity scores alone. For example, Figure 5 shows that there is a much higher number of subculture platforms outside the U.S. than in the U.S. We believe this could be due to Reddit’s popularity in the U.S., where it may function as a mega-forum, absorbing many stand-alone forums.

    Additionally, looking at Figure 5, we see that subculture logic is first (by a large margin) in terms of raw frequency though it’s fourth in terms of popularity scores, implying that subculture logic is home to a broad array of platforms that cater to smaller userbases. Conversely, we can see that chat and social network logic have similar popularity scores to subculture logic but at much smaller raw frequencies, suggesting they are home to a less diverse array of platforms that host larger userbases.

    To further investigate the differences in popularity concentration across logics, we calculated the average popularity for logics with at least eight platforms in the top 100 (see Figure 6). The frequency cutoff was eight, because the remaining logics had frequencies of five or less—small sample sizes that we believed were likely to give noisy results. The formula for a logic’s average popularity was: popularity score/frequency.

    Chat logic has the highest average popularity at 80, followed by creator and social network logic at 61. On the low end is subculture logic at 33, with Q&A falling in between at 58. These findings make sense. Subculture logic is organized around discrete, insular communities, which have a ceiling on their potential userbase—there are only so many yarn enthusiasts. Conversely, chat, creator, and social network logics are typically organized around functionality that has a much higher potential userbase—hence Facebook’s mission to “connect the world.” Q&A reasonably falls somewhere in between.

    Lastly, another interesting finding from the raw frequencies in Figure 5 is that the U.S. is home to the majority of low-frequency logics. There are many possible explanations—we will offer two:

    Social media is a space for experimentation in the U.S., and different logics continue to emerge as it matures. This is true in other countries and languages as well, and we are likely missing some of the more niche experiments due to our linguistic and cultural isolation. We would be grateful for pointers to social media in other countries that exemplify these less-common logics or are introducing new logics entirely.

    Political and cultural differences may play a role in the popularity of different social media logics. Take alt-tech logic, which as we note in the earlier chapter covers platforms, like Gab, Parler, and TheDonald.win, that market themselves as bastions of free speech and mainly serve right-wing communities that have been deplatformed from mainstream platforms. Why could alt-tech be more likely to emerge in the U.S.? First, the U.S. receives disproportionate attention from the mainstream platforms because they are based in the U.S. and make most of their money in the U.S. This makes it more likely that fringe groups in the U.S. will be noticed, moderated, and kicked off. Second, political freedoms in the U.S. mean that fringe groups are allowed to create and maintain their own social media spaces. Third, the U.S. has a large population, making it more likely that a given U.S. platform will be featured in the top 100.

    Conclusion

    As we said above, we do not claim our top 100 list is definitive or comprehensive, so any findings derived from it should be treated with caution. Even so, we think the results demonstrate the benefits of combining an empirical approach with a rich theoretical perspective when studying social media.

    The findings that stick with us are: (1) social is eating the world; (2) social is global; and (3) social is much more than Facebook and Twitter. These findings get at the core of why we undertook this mapping project in the first place: To move past the problems of today’s social media, we need to overcome those assumptions and their associated myths and reach a more sophisticated understanding of the topic. The diversity of social media is clear, as are the possibilities, when we reject U.S.- and Facebook-centrism and strive for more complex thinking about the domain.

    NameLogicPopularityCountry
    YouTubeCreator100U.S.
    FacebookSocial Network99U.S.
    WhatsAppChat98India
    FB MessengerChat97U.S.
    WeChatChat96China
    InstagramSocial Network95U.S.
    TikTokCreator94U.S.
    QQChat93China
    DouyinCreator92China
    Sina WeiboSocial Network91China
    SnapchatSocial Network90China
    RedditSubculture89U.S.
    PinterestSocial Bookmarking88U.S.
    TelegramChat87India
    TwitterSocial Network86U.S.
    QuoraQ&A85India
    LinkedInSocial Network84U.S.
    ImgurCreator83U.S.
    LineChat82Japan
    imoChat81China
    BrainlyQ&A80U.S.
    douban.comSocial Network79China
    Yy.comCreator78China
    TwitchCreator77U.S.
    VKSocial Network76Russia
    Babytree.comSubculture75China
    DiscordChat74U.S.
    LikeeCreator73China
    SlackChat72U.S.
    Wattpad.comCreator71India
    csdn.netQ&A70China
    zhanqi.tvCreator69China
    tianya.cnSubculture68China
    ok.ruSocial Network 67Russia
    zalo.meChat 66Vietnam
    Stack OverflowQ&A 65U.S.
    DeviantArtSubculture 64U.S.
    VSCOCreator 63U.S.
    NextDoorLocal 62U.S.
    aparat.comCreator 61Iran
    medium.comCreator 60U.S.
    Pixnet.netSocial Network 59Taiwan
    cnblogs.comSubculture 58China
    TumblrSocial Network 57U.S.
    6.cnCreator 56China
    Bilibili.comSubculture 55China
    stackexchange.comQ&A 54U.S.
    Tradingview.comSubculture 53U.S.
    slideshare.netCreator 52India
    zhihu.comQ&A 51China
    Behance.netCreator 50India
    nicovideo.jpSubculture 49Japan
    Steamcommunity.comSubculture 48U.S.
    kakao.comSocial Network 47Korea
    ameblo.jpCreator 46Japan
    9gag.comChan 45Germany
    dcard.twSubculture 44Taiwan
    namasha.comCreator 43Iran
    LiveJournalSocial Network 42Russia
    ninisite.comSubculture 41Iran
    4chanChan 40U.S.
    flickr.comCreator 39U.S.
    ptt.ccSubculture 38Taiwan
    kizlarsoruyor.comQ&A 37Turkey
    5ch.netChan 36Japan
    hatenablog.comCreator 35Japan
    renren.comSocial Network 34China
    plurk.comSocial Network33India
    eyny.comSubculture32Taiwan
    lihkg.comSubculture31Hong Kong
    xing.comSubculture30Germany
    miaopai.comCreator29China
    dxy.cnSubculture28China
    FetLifeSubculture27U.S.
    yammer.comEnterprise Social26U.S.
    Network
    weheartit.comSocial Bookmarking25India
    ParlerAlt-Tech24U.S.
    letterboxd.comSubculture23U.S.
    OmegleChat22U.S.
    wykop.plSubculture21Poland
    workplace.comEnterprise Social20U.S.
    Network
    ask.fmQ&A19Egypt
    Taringa!Subculture18Argentina
    MixiSocial Network17Japan
    DLiveCrypto16U.S.
    MeWeAlt-Tech15U.S.
    exblog.jpCreator14Japan
    2chan.netChan13Japan
    skyrock.comSocial Network12France
    mydigit.cnSubculture11China
    NewGroundsSubculture10U.S.
    nnmclub.toSubculture9Netherlands
    Hacker NewsSubculture8U.S.
    FarkSubculture7U.S.
    fuliba2020.netChan6China
    computerbase.deSubculture5Germany
    instiz.netSubculture4Korea
    GabAlt-Tech3U.S.
    skoob.com.brSubculture2Brazil
    BlindSubculture1U.S.
    Figure 7. Top 100: The most popular social media platforms

    Footnotes

    1. 1.

      Top Websites Ranking, Similarweb (Mar. 2022), https://www.similarweb.com/top-websites/category/computers-electronics-and-technology/social-networks-and-online-communities/ [https://perma.cc/6YQE-5R6C].

    2. 2.

      The Top 500 Sites on the Web, Alexa, https://www.alexa.com/topsites [https://perma.cc/4F4V-7LSQ] (last visited Apr. 20, 2022).

    3. 3.

      List of Social Networking Services, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_social_networking_services [https://perma.cc/2FA9-C6VP] (May 10, 2022, 5:01 PM).

    4. 4.

      knightcolumbia, Top 100 Social Media Platforms, GitHub (Jan. 2021), https://github.com/knightcolumbia/top-100-social-media [https://perma.cc/79N3-BP76].

    Chand Rajendra-Nicolucci is a research fellow at the Knight Institute.

    Ethan Zuckerman is associate professor of public policy, information and communication at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, director of the Initiative on Digital Public Infrastructure, and was the 2020-2021 visiting research scholar at the Knight Institute.

    Filed under

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Get the latest news about our events, research, advocacy, litigation, and more in your inbox.