Lawsuit · Ongoing

Margolin v. National Association of Immigration Judges

A lawsuit challenging a government policy silencing immigration judges.

Case Information

Nat’l Ass’n of Immigration Judges v. Owen, No. 1:20-cv-00731 (E.D. Va.), No. 20-1868 and 23-2235 (4th Cir.), Margolin v. Nat’l Ass’n of Immigration Judges, No. 25A662, No. 25-767, 25-1009.

Illustration of a judge in glasses with a hand covering their mouth, in blue and pink
Marly Gallardo

Status

On November 17, 2026, NAIJ filed a petition for Supreme Court review.

Sections

    About

    On July 1, 2020, the Knight Institute filed a lawsuit on behalf of the National Association of Immigration Judges (NAIJ) challenging a Justice Department policy that imposes an unconstitutional prior restraint on the speech of immigration judges. The policy categorically prohibits immigration judges from speaking or writing publicly in their personal capacities about immigration or about the agency that employs them.

    For years, immigration judges regularly spoke at conferences, guest lectured at universities and law schools, participated in immigration-law trainings, and spoke to local community groups, all in their personal capacities. But starting in 2017, the Executive Office for Immigration Review issued a series of speaking-engagement policies that sharply curtailed their ability to speak publicly in their personal capacities

    The lawsuit argues that the currently operative policy violates the First Amendment right of immigration judges to speak publicly on matters of public concern, and the First Amendment right of the public to hear them. It also argues that the policy is void for vagueness under the First and Fifth Amendments.

    Filings

    Click to highlight response chains

    Key Documents

    Supreme Court (26-XXXX)

    4th Cir. (23-2235)

    Supreme Court (25-1009)

    Supreme Court (25-767)

    Supreme Court (25A662)

    4th Cir. (20-1868)

    1. Amicus Briefs (in support of Plaintiff)

    E.D. Va.

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Get the latest news about our events, research, advocacy, litigation, and more in your inbox.