Press Statements

Immigration Judges Return to Supreme Court, Seeking Right to Challenge Gag Order in Federal Court

Without a clear path to court, any administration could silence federal workers, the Knight Institute says

November 17, 2026

Read time 3 min.

Sections

    WASHINGTON—The National Association of Immigration Judges (NAIJ), represented by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, today asked the U.S. Supreme Court to let the association’s members go directly to federal court to challenge a Justice Department policy that imposes a sweeping gag order on what immigration judges can say publicly.

    “This case is about whether the government can gag its own employees and then make it nearly impossible for them to challenge that gag in court,” said Ramya Krishnan, a senior staff attorney with the Knight First Amendment Institute. “No one should have to put their job on the line to defend their right to speak. With immigration at the center of national debate, Americans should be able to hear what immigration judges have to say.”

    In 2020, the Knight Institute filed this lawsuit on behalf of NAIJ, challenging an Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) policy that prohibits immigration judges from speaking publicly in their personal capacities about immigration or the agency that employs them. A district court dismissed the case in 2023, holding that the Civil Service Reform Act (CSRA) of 1978 requires such claims to go through an administrative process rather than federal court.

    In June 2025, the Fourth Circuit revived the case, expressing concern that Trump administration actions may have undermined the agencies charged with hearing federal employee claims—the Office of Special Counsel and the Merit Systems Protection Board. It sent the case back to the district court to determine whether that administrative system was still functioning as Congress intended. The court also held, though, that if the system was functioning as intended immigration judges would have to pursue their challenge through that administrative process.

    Earlier this year, the Supreme Court summarily reversed that decision on procedural grounds and declined to review NAIJ’s separate argument that federal employees should be able to go directly to court to challenge broad restrictions on their speech. It returned the case to the Fourth Circuit, which affirmed the district court’s dismissal in August without ruling on whether the policy violates the First Amendment.

    “Judges do not turn in their right to free speech when they put on the robe,” said Holly A. D’Andrea, president of the National Association of Immigration Judges. “Our country was designed to be governed by public reason, not private silence. Silencing judges deprives the public of a key perspective on the rule of law.”

    Because the Supreme Court reversed the earlier Fourth Circuit ruling about the CSRA’s functioning, today’s petition presents a more focused question: whether immigration judges must pursue their challenge through an administrative process that does not guarantee any—let alone meaningful—judicial review of their time-sensitive constitutional claims. Under the Fourth Circuit’s ruling, the only guaranteed pathway for an immigration judge to challenge EOIR’s policy in federal court is to violate the policy, get punished, and then challenge that punishment.

    The petition warns that this ruling threatens to create “a First Amendment black hole”: “The federal government could categorically forbid federal employees from engaging in even private speech about gun rights, health care, vaccines, university admissions, or the war in Gaza—and judicial review of these brazenly unconstitutional policies would come only with the blessing of an agency official, and only after protracted and futile administrative proceedings.”

    Even eventual judicial review would come too late to remedy the harm, the petition argues: “The ability of federal employees to contribute to currently unfolding debates cannot be regained once lost.”

    Read the cert petition here.

    Read more about the case here.

    Attorneys on the case include Ramya Krishnan, Alex Abdo, Xiangnong (George) Wang, Zoe Rubin, and Jameel Jaffer for the Knight First Amendment Institute, and Victor M. Glasberg of Victor M. Glasberg & Associates in Alexandria, VA.

    For more information, contact: [email protected].

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Get the latest news about our events, research, advocacy, litigation, and more in your inbox.