Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Since taking office for a second term, President Trump has issued a wave of executive orders attempting to place conditions on how recipients of federal funding can speak and associate. Contemporary First Amendment doctrine is confusing and even incoherent on the question of when the government may regulate speech by imposing conditions on federal funding. The Supreme Court has said that Congress has broad power to tax and spend for the general welfare, and that this power encompasses the authority to impose limits on the use of the funds to ensure that they are used for the purpose Congress intends. At the same time, the First Amendment precludes the government from denying a benefit on a basis that infringes the applicant’s freedom of speech, even if the applicant does not have an entitlement to that benefit.
This blog channel highlights the Institute’s ongoing research and education efforts related to federal funding and the First Amendment.
-
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Facts and Feelings: First Amendment Challenges to Mandated Ideological Compliance for Scientific Grants
The restrictions imposed on researchers by Trump's "gender ideology" executive order are fundamentally incompatible with the scientific process
By Kendra Albert -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Congress Could Do Something About the Weaponization of Federal Funding to Silence Speech. For Now, It Probably Won’t.
What Congress can do to take back control of the funding process
By Kate Ruane -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Federal Funding as a Jawbone
The First Amendment's prohibition on jawboning makes the government's attempts to suppress speech at universities like Harvard unconstitutional
By Evelyn Douek -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
The Strange Use of Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard to Control Teaching and Learning
The Trump administration is distorting Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act to justify its assertion of control over universities
By Olatunde C. Johnson -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Employing the Anti-Leveraging Test to Effectively Protect Grantee Speech
An interpretation of Agency for International Development
By Sam Bagenstos -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Speech-Related Conditions on Federal Funding in the University Context
How Supreme Court doctrine on academic freedom might impact cases about conditions on federal funding
By Frederick P. Schaffer -
Deep Dive: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Conditional Funding Can Raise Difficult Legal Questions. Trump’s Freezes Don’t.
Despite some confusion in the doctrine, the Trump administration's use of the funding power is clearly unlawful
By Michael C. Dorf -
Institute Update: Federal Funding and the First Amendment
Knight Institute Initiative on “Federal Funding and the First Amendment” Draws Leading Scholars and Litigators
On Friday, May 23, the Knight Institute will host a closed convening at Columbia University to explore the question of when the government may regulate speech by imposing conditions on federal funding.
By Katy Glenn Bass -
Litigation
Press Statement
USDA Reverses Course, Commits to Restore Purged Climate Webpages in Response to Farmers’ Lawsuit
The Trump administration will restore access to vital resources for climate-smart agriculture, forest conservation, climate change adaptation, and rural clean energy projects
Learn MoreResearch
Essays and Scholarship
Protecting Immigrant Activists From U.S. Government Retaliation: Lessons From First Amendment Litigation
Immigrant activists in the U.S. face legal and structural barriers when fighting First Amendment retaliation.
Learn MoreResearch
Essays and Scholarship
AI as Normal Technology
Learn More
Litigation
Press Statement
Fourth Circuit Revives Challenge to Policy Silencing Immigration Judges
The independence of agencies charged with protecting employee rights has been compromised by Trump administration, court suggests
Learn More